Bulletin 12 - Falls
Falls
|
Table 1 shows similar overall female and male rates of fall related
death. This contrasts with the usual pattern of higher male rates for most
causes of injury. When age specific data are considered, it can be seen that
highest rates of fall-related deaths occur in the older age groups (Figure 3).
Females have lower fall-related death rates than males until the older age
groups. Male and female rates tend to converge from middle age, driven by an
increasing rate of fall-related deaths among older women. Falls are the leading
cause of injury related death for females aged 65 years and over, accounting
for 52% of all female injury related deaths. |
 |
Further evidence for the importance of falls is shown by the overall rate of
female hospitalisation due to fall-related injuries which is the highest of any
specific cause group and exceeds that for males (Table 1). Victorian figures
also suggest that falls are the leading cause of injury related hospitalisation
for females aged 65 years and over. In that State, the annual average
fall-related hospital admission for that group was 52% in the period July 1987
to July 1993 [14].
|
For hospitalisation, the upward trend in the rate ratio commences at an earlier
age than for deaths, and by around 55 years of age, the female rate exceeds the
male rate (Figure 4). The reason why older women have a higher rate of
fall-related hospital admission than older men is not known. One possible
explanation is that, as women grow older, they are more likely than men to
sustain a serious injury when they do fall. More research is needed to
understand if these women have a greater risk of falling than men, and to
determine if the risk of injury or death following a fall is different for
women. Emergency department attendance data allow us to begin examining the
nature of the falls experience of older women. |
 |
The ISIS data collection contains 17,650 cases of fall-related injury
amongst women aged 45 years and over. In 51% of these cases, the women who fell
sustained one or more fractures. The proportion of women suffering fractures
after a fall increased with age, consistent with a belief that osteoporosis, a
condition associated with ageing, is a contributing factor in this type of
injury. The injuries sustained by this group of women most frequently affected
the upper and lower extremities, with upper extremity fractures (eg. shoulder
or humerus) more common at younger ages than hip fractures.
An examination of the fall locations recorded in the ISIS data shows that as
women get older, there is a decline in falling on a road or footpath and an
increase in falling in residential indoor settings (Table 3). This probably
reflects a change in exposure patterns as the more frail, higher risk women
spend more time indoors. Knowledge of such changes in women's exposure patterns
can assist in better targeting of falls prevention activities.
Table 3: Location of falls leading to injuries in females seen at ISIS
hospital emergency departments
| Location of fall |
Age 45-59 |
Age 60-74 |
Age 75+ |
| % | % | % |
| Road or footpath | 15.0 | 16.7 | 9.3 |
| Home-indoor | 25.0 | 31.5 | 39.2 |
| Home-outdoor | 24.0 | 24.8 | 16.5 |
| Other | 36.1 | 27.0 | 34.9 |
| Total | 100.0 | 100.0 | 100.0 |
Prevention strategies suggested in the literature [15] include:
- improving the management of medication for older people to reduce their
risk of falling;
- encouraging participation in exercise programs that incorporate facets such
as balance and gait assessment, and physiotherapy, to increase muscle strength
and improve fitness and mobility;
- modifying the environments of older people through measures such as
improving indoor lighting and installing grab rails in private houses and
nursing homes;
- further developing the utility and effectiveness of devices such as
protective hip pads designed to be added to clothing to reduce the impact of
falls;
- treatment and prevention of osteoporosis to minimise the risk of fractures
resulting from falls.
There is limited research to indicate the
effectiveness of any individual intervention. A 1994 US case-control study
suggested that a multifactorial approach has merit [16]. A randomised
controlled study to evaluate the effectiveness of some fall prevention
interventions is being undertaken by the Monash University Accident Research
Centre and the City of White Horse in Victoria. This is one of several such
studies underway. The results of work of this kind will add to our ability to
assess which interventions are best suited to the Australian context.
14. Watt GM. Hospitalised injuries Victoria, July 1987 - June 1993. Melbourne:
Monash University Accident Research Centre, 1995; Report No. 67.
15. Fildes B (ed). Injuries among older people: falls at home and pedestrian
accidents. Melbourne: Collins Dove, 1994; Vic Health Foundation Monograph
Series, pp. 219-222.
16. Tinetti ME, Baker DI, McAvay G, Claus EB, Garrett P, Gottschalk M, Koch ML,
Trainor MS, Horwitz RI. A multifactorial intervention to reduce the risk of
falling among elderly people living in the community. New England J Medicine
1994; 331: 821-827.
|