Coronial Study - Executive Summary
Executive Summary
Responding to the initiative of coroners in
Australia, the National Injury Surveillance Unit agreed to undertake
a feasibility study for a national coronial information system.
This paper contains the results of this investigation.
Major Findings
Technical Recommendations
Recommendations of Coroners and Users
- Current coronial information systems are not able to provide
the quality of information or efficient access to information
which is required by both the coroners and major users of coronial
data. They are mainly paper-based, have few systematic ways of
indexing data and vary in terms of detail and quality of information
- There is a commitment by coroners to the development of a
better information system and the sharing of this information
with appropriate, interested parties.
- Development is limited by lack of resources, lack of familiarity
with and access to modern computer technology in many jurisdictions,
and a fragmented approach by the many users of information.
- There is a need to develop a systematic way of investigating
and recording information about deaths, taking into account the
needs of major users of information, and using systematic coding
procedures.
- Major users expend a great deal of effort and large amounts
of money accessing coronial data. Much of this is due to the
way in which records are stored and a lack of appropriate indexing
systems. Even where information from coroners is coded by external
agencies, the resulting indexing systems are not provided to the
coroner for use in the performance of coronial duties.
- Reallocation of these resources to an efficient computerised
system would allow ongoing operation of the system with increased
utility of coronial information to all users.
- The estimated maximum cost of establishing the system is approximately
$270,000. Annual running costs would be around $210,000. Use
and upgrading of existing facilities should reduce these costs.
- A national coronial information system will contribute significantly
to planning the prevention of death and injury. This has the
potential to produce major reductions in the costs of injury to
Australian society.
The following recommendations were developed in the course of
this project.
- It is recommended that coroners and administrative personnel
from each jurisdiction develop plans for computerised administrative
systems that include at least a common core of information which
can support a national coronial information system. This may include
cooperative development of systems or merging into a single system.
- It is recommended that the Australian Coroners' Society (ACS),
in conjunction with specialists with an interest in particular
causes of death, design standard investigation and recording protocols
for significant classes of death and promulgate these for the
investigation process.
- It is recommended that the ACS develop a set of standards
for the reporting of findings and promulgate this for use by all
coroners in Australia.
- It is recommended that the ACS develop a standard approach
to facilitate the reporting of matters which are transferred to
other courts and, where necessary, that coroners request that
changes be made to Coroner's Acts to permit this approach to be
implemented.
- It is recommended that a strategy be developed by interested
parties, including the coroners and major users, to develop a
national coroners' database during the 1995-96 financial year,
with a view to stage one operation commencing in early 1996.
A meeting of representatives of coronial jurisdictions and major
user groups was convened on 27-28 October 1994 to respond to the
draft report of the needs and feasibility study.
The meeting endorsed these five recommendations and made the following
additional recommendations:
- That the ACS:
- endorse the findings of the feasibility study;
- approach the State and Federal attorneys-general to gain support
and resources for the development of a national coronial information
system (NCIS);
- seek the formal commitment of major users to the establishment
of the NCIS;
- establish a timetable for the implementation of the NCIS;
- establish a steering committee whose charter includes the
oversight of the establishment of the NCIS, nomination of an auspicing
body and site of operations, and establishment of ongoing management
mechanisms. The steering committee shall include State coroners
or their nominees (empowered to act on their behalf) and representatives
of major user groups.
- That each coronial jurisdiction take steps to inform its Attorney-General
and other relevant decision makers of its support for the development
of an NCIS as outlined in the needs and feasibility report.
- That organisations which are major users of coronial information
indicate in writing to the ACS:
- in principle endorsement of an NCIS;
- ways in which they can facilitate and resource the development
and operation of the NCIS;
- appropriate points of contact for further negotiation.
|